Can a Mississippi Judge Set Child Support Without Proof of Income, or Leave Your Visitation Up to the Other Parent?
On November 10, 2026, the Mississippi Court of Appeals threw out a $600 a month child support order because the judge never showed how she arrived at the number. The same court let stand an order that put the father's visitation entirely in the mother's hands. Both halves of this decision matter to any parent in a Mississippi custody or support case.
The case is McLain v. Davis, No. 2025-CA-00453-COA (Miss. Ct. App. Nov. 10, 2026) (opinion PDF). As of November 15, 2026, the decision is not final; either side may ask for rehearing through November 24, 2026. William McLain and Tristan Davis were never married. Their son was born in May 2023. The Department of Human Services filed a paternity case that December, and Ms. Davis petitioned for custody, supervised visitation and child support. A September 2024 temporary order gave her custody and set support at $350 a month. At the March 2025 final hearing in the Jackson County Chancery Court, Mr. McLain represented himself.
What the Court Decided
The Court of Appeals described the final hearing as "extremely informal." The chancellor asked questions, the parties answered under oath, no witnesses were called, and neither side was allowed to cross-examine the other (¶ 2). Mr. McLain filled out his Rule 8.05 financial statement during a recess. Every line read zero except $31,000 in credit card debt (¶ 7). He said he had not held a job in nine years and had lived on money a friend gave him, now gone (¶¶ 6, 7). The chancellor raised support to $600 a month, pointing to large bank deposits and finding that he had the ability to work (¶ 8), and ordered that his visitation would be "exercised at Davis' sole discretion" (¶ 1).
Child support: reversed. All ten judges agreed on this part. Nothing in the record supported $600 a month. The bank records discussed at the hearing were never entered into evidence (¶ 6), and the chancellor "failed to establish a monthly adjusted gross income and failed to show how she calculated the amount of income she imputed to McLain" (¶ 11). Mississippi Code Section 43-19-101 sets a guideline of 14 percent of adjusted gross income for one child, requires a written or on-the-record finding before a judge departs from the guideline, and, in subsection (5), says that "Imputation of income shall not be based upon a standard amount in lieu of fact-gathering." The court sent the support question back for findings that show the math (¶¶ 9 to 11, 17).
Visitation: affirmed, by a five to five vote. The lead opinion said the chancellor did not deny visitation; she placed it in the mother's discretion, and that was within her broad power to restrict visitation in the child's best interest (¶¶ 12, 15). Mr. McLain never filed a pleading asking for visitation and offered no proposal beyond saying he wanted to see his son (¶ 12). If she "unreasonably denies" visitation, the lead opinion said, he can bring the matter back to the chancery court (¶ 15).
Five judges disagreed. Presiding Judge Wilson, joined by four colleagues, wrote that an order giving one parent sole discretion over visitation gives the other parent "no legally enforceable visitation rights" (¶ 23), that such an order should not be entered without evidence and findings that "even supervised visitation would be harmful to the child" (¶ 26), and that the record showed only that Mr. McLain was homeless, unemployed and had a gambling problem (¶ 26). Because the court split evenly, the visitation order stands.
Mr. McLain also asked for a different chancellor on remand. The court held that request must be made to the chancellor first under Uniform Chancery Court Rule 1.11(C) (¶ 16).
Why This Matters
The support ruling matters to any parent who shows up without a lawyer, without pay stubs, or with a confusing financial story. A chancellor can impute income to a parent who is not working. What a chancellor cannot do is pick a number. The statute requires fact-gathering about the specific parent: past earnings, assets, job skills, education, health, criminal record, the local job market and similar factors, and under McLain the judgment has to show how the court got from those facts to the dollar figure. The Court of Appeals relied on Huseth v. Huseth, a 2014 Mississippi Supreme Court decision that sent a support award back for a fuller look at what the father could actually pay (¶ 11). The rule binds the court even when the judge finds the parent evasive, as this chancellor did.
The visitation ruling is a warning. Mississippi law has long said that a judge may restrict a parent's visitation only when there is evidence that the restriction is "necessary to avoid harm to the child." Harrington v. Harrington, 648 So. 2d 543, 545 (Miss. 1994). Both opinions in McLain cite that line and part ways on what it means when a parent shows up with no plan. Half the court treated the mother's discretion as a workable starting point the father could later ask the court to revisit. The other half treated it as a denial of visitation with no findings of harm. A parent who wants time with a child cannot count on the court to build the request for him.
What This Means in Mississippi
The child support holding carries a majority of the court. Once the decision is final, that part of a published Court of Appeals opinion is precedent in every chancery court in the state, including the chancery courts of Forrest, Lamar, Marion, Pearl River and Perry Counties, where our family law team appears. The visitation ruling rests on a five to five vote, so the decision settles only the result in that case. Three practical points follow.
First, Section 43-19-101 is the framework for child support in Mississippi, and in McLain the Court of Appeals held the chancellor to its text. The guideline percentages, the written finding required for any departure, the fact-gathering required for imputed income, and the subsection (4) findings required when adjusted gross income is under $10,000 or over $100,000 all apply in Forrest and Lamar County chancery court. The Uniform Chancery Court Rule 8.05 financial statement is where the judge starts. In McLain, a statement full of zeros left the chancellor with nothing to work from.
Second, visitation has to be pleaded and proved like anything else. The parent who wants visitation should file a response or counter-petition asking for a specific schedule and be ready to tell the court how, when and where visits would work. Harrington requires evidence of harm before a court restricts visitation, and McLain shows that a parent who offers nothing may end up with an order that depends on the other parent's goodwill.
Third, the custody rules changed this year. House Bill 1662 amended Section 93-5-24 to create a rebuttable presumption that joint custody and equally shared parenting time are in the child's best interest, and a court that does not award them must document its reasons unless the parents agree on custody or jointly ask for a different arrangement. That presumption applies only to initial temporary and initial final custody orders entered after July 1, 2026, and it does not apply to modifications. The McLain order was entered in March 2025, before the change. A parent who wants something other than equal time in a new divorce or custody case to which Section 93-5-24 applies has to rebut the presumption with evidence.
What to Do If This Affects You
- If you were ordered to pay support with no explanation of the number, get the judgment and the hearing transcript. If the court imputed income without findings, McLain and Section 43-19-101 give you the argument. Appeal deadlines run from the date the judgment is entered.
- If your visitation is "at the discretion" of the other parent, keep a written record of every request and every response. The lead opinion in McLain says a parent who is unreasonably denied visitation can go back to the chancery court, and that record is what you will show the judge.
- If you have a custody or support hearing coming up, fill out the Rule 8.05 statement completely and truthfully, bring the documents behind every line and your witnesses, and put a specific visitation proposal in writing before the hearing.
- If you were served with a paternity or custody petition, read the summons. Custody and support actions use a Rule 4(i) summons (formerly Rule 81(d)) that sets a court date, and a properly served parent who does not appear at that first setting gets no further notice or process. File a written response asking for the custody and visitation terms you want.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a Mississippi judge make me pay child support if I do not have a job?
Yes. A chancellor can impute income to a parent who is not working. In McLain v. Davis (Miss. Ct. App. Nov. 10, 2026), though, the Court of Appeals reversed a $600 a month award because the judge never established the father's adjusted gross income or showed how the imputed figure was calculated. Mississippi Code Section 43-19-101(5) says imputed income cannot be based on a standard amount in place of fact-gathering about the parent's assets, job skills, education, health, work history and the local job market.
How is child support calculated in Mississippi?
Section 43-19-101 sets guideline percentages of the paying parent's adjusted gross income: 14 percent for one child, 20 percent for two, 22 percent for three, 24 percent for four, and 26 percent for five or more. The guideline is a rebuttable presumption. A judge who departs from it must make a written finding or a specific finding on the record that applying the guideline would be unjust or inappropriate, and when adjusted gross income is under $10,000 or over $100,000 a year, the judge must make written findings on whether the guideline is reasonable.
Can a judge leave my visitation up to the other parent?
In McLain v. Davis, the Court of Appeals split five to five on that question and the order stood. The lead opinion treated an order placing visitation in the custodial parent's discretion as a permissible restriction on a father who had not asked for visitation in any pleading and offered no plan, and said he could return to court if visits were unreasonably denied. Five judges would have reversed because the order gave him no enforceable visitation rights and there were no findings that even supervised visitation would harm the child. Mississippi Supreme Court precedent, Harrington v. Harrington (1994), requires evidence that a restriction on visitation is necessary to avoid harm to the child.
What is a Rule 8.05 financial statement and why does it matter?
Uniform Chancery Court Rule 8.05 requires each party in a domestic case involving money or property to provide a financial statement, the prior year's tax returns and an employment and earnings history unless the court excuses it or the parties waive it with the court's permission. In McLain, the father's statement listed zero on every line except $31,000 in credit card debt, and the chancellor relied on bank records that were discussed at the hearing but never entered into evidence. A complete statement with documents behind it is the foundation of any support ruling.
Does the new 50/50 custody presumption apply to my case?
House Bill 1662, effective July 1, 2026, amended Section 93-5-24 to create a rebuttable presumption that joint custody and equally shared parenting time are in the child's best interest. It applies only to initial temporary and initial final custody orders entered after July 1, 2026. It does not apply to modifications of earlier orders. The McLain custody order was entered in March 2025, so the presumption played no part in that case.
Who handles child support and visitation cases at Lowrey, Fortner, & Miri P.A.?
Kimberly-Joy (KJ) Miri and Shawn M. Lowrey lead the family law practice at Lowrey, Fortner, & Miri P.A., which appears regularly in the Forrest County and Lamar County chancery courts and across the Pine Belt in custody, visitation, paternity and child support cases. Call (601) 582-5015. After hours, leave a voicemail and we will call you back.
Keep Reading
The Section 43-19-101 guidelines, what counts as income, imputed income and how support is modified.
How paternity, custody and visitation are decided when the parents were never married.
What the law says about a father's custody and visitation, and how to present your case.
Talk to a Lawyer
A support order can follow you until your child is grown, and a visitation order decides whether you see your child. Lowrey, Fortner, & Miri P.A. handles custody, visitation, paternity and child support cases in the chancery courts of Forrest County, Lamar County and across the Pine Belt, and reviews chancery judgments for appeal. Learn more on our family law and Hattiesburg child custody pages.
Facing a Custody or Child Support Hearing?
Call Lowrey, Fortner, & Miri P.A. before your court date. Every case turns on its own facts and law, and prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
(601) 582-5015Kimberly-Joy (KJ) Miri is a partner at Lowrey, Fortner, & Miri P.A. in Hattiesburg. She focuses her practice on family law, including divorce and child custody cases in South Mississippi's chancery courts.