Can a Mississippi Judge Overrule Your Lawyer's Jury Strike? A Murder Conviction Reversed
On November 3, 2026, the Mississippi Court of Appeals reversed a Yazoo County murder conviction because the trial judge refused a jury strike the defense had every right to make. The juror the defense tried to remove went on to serve as the jury's foreman.
The case is White v. State, No. 2025-KA-00530-COA (Miss. Ct. App. Nov. 3, 2026) (opinion PDF). Dexter White was indicted for capital murder and armed robbery. The jury acquitted him of the armed robbery and convicted him of second-degree murder, a lesser offense included in the capital charge. He raised nine issues on appeal; the court reached one, the jury strike, and ordered a new trial. White, slip op. at ¶1. All ten judges of the Court of Appeals agreed on that result.
What the Court Decided
Every felony trial starts with jury selection. Each side can ask the judge to remove a juror for cause, which requires a reason the judge accepts, and each side has a set number of peremptory strikes, which remove a juror with no reason given. In a capital case each side gets twelve; in other criminal cases each side gets six. Miss. Code Ann. § 99-17-3 (Rev. 2020). The main limit on how a strike may be used comes from Batson v. Kentucky, 476 U.S. 79 (1986): a strike cannot be used to remove a juror because of race.
During White's jury selection, the defense first asked to remove Juror 30 for cause. He knew the district attorney, he knew the State's star witness, Cedrick Jones, and he had spoken at Jones's church several times. The juror said he could be fair, and the judge denied the challenge for cause. White, slip op. at ¶7. The defense then struck him peremptorily.
By that point the defense had used seven strikes: six against white jurors and the seventh against Juror 30, who is Black. The State raised what Mississippi courts call a reverse-Batson challenge, complaining that "six out of the seven strikes from the Defense were all white." Id. at ¶3. The judge asked defense counsel to explain all seven. For Juror 30, counsel repeated the church and witness connections and added that no race-neutral reason was owed for him because he was Black. The State did not object to the strike, though it noted again that the juror had said he could be fair. The judge denied the strike without comment, and Juror 30 took his seat and later became foreman. Id. at ¶¶4-5, 8-10.
The Court of Appeals held that was error for a simple reason. The State's complaint was that the defense was striking white jurors, and Juror 30 was never part of it, so the defense never had to justify striking him. Once the reason was given, the court "had no ground on which to refuse it, and doing so was error." Id. at ¶15. A peremptory strike needs less justification than a challenge for cause. Id. at ¶11 (quoting Manning v. State, 735 So. 2d 323, 339 (Miss. 1999)).
Then came the remedy. Under the Mississippi Supreme Court's decision in Hardison v. State, 94 So. 3d 1092, 1101-02 (Miss. 2012), a trial court "cannot deprive defendants of their right to a peremptory strike" without a proper Batson analysis, and when the wrongly seated juror "actually sits on the panel that convicts the defendant," prejudice "is automatically presumed" (internal quotation marks omitted). The Court of Appeals applied that rule and sent the case back to Yazoo County for a new trial. White, slip op. at ¶¶14-17. White did not have to show that the foreman was unfair to him.
Judge McCarty wrote separately, joined in part by two judges, to say the State's own strikes raised a second problem. On the first panel the State kept all eight white jurors and struck six of the ten Black jurors. The defense objected, and the trial court skipped the first step of Batson and announced there was no violation. In his view, that alone would have sent the case back for a limited Batson hearing under Miles v. State, 346 So. 3d 840 (Miss. 2022). White, slip op. at ¶¶21-27 (McCarty, J., specially concurring).
Why This Matters
Jury selection is where a trial is shaped, and a peremptory strike is the last tool a defendant has against a juror who has close ties to the other side and still says he can be fair once a cause challenge fails. In White's case the cause challenge failed, the peremptory strike was the backstop, and the judge took it away.
Mississippi treats that as a serious error. The United States Supreme Court held in Rivera v. Illinois, 556 U.S. 148, 157 (2009), that the federal Constitution does not require automatic reversal when a state judge wrongly denies a peremptory strike in good faith and the seated jurors are qualified and unbiased; the remedy belongs to state law. Mississippi had already answered that question in Stewart v. State, 662 So. 2d 552, 557 (Miss. 1995): the right to peremptory challenges is a state-created right, and the arbitrary denial of one violates due process. White, slip op. at ¶¶12-13 (quoting Stewart). Hardison added the presumption of prejudice in 2012.
Batson runs both ways, and the three steps are the same whoever objects. First, the objecting side must show facts that raise an inference of discrimination. Second, only then must the striking side give a race-neutral reason. Third, the judge decides whether that reason is a pretext. White, slip op. at ¶20 (McCarty, J., specially concurring) (quoting Johnson v. California, 545 U.S. 162, 168 (2005)). In White's case the judge demanded a reason for a strike the State's objection never covered.
The remedy depends on what the record shows. When a trial court leaves the Batson steps incomplete, the Mississippi Supreme Court held in Miles that the case goes back for a limited hearing, confined to the record made at the original jury selection, so the analysis can be finished. Miles, 346 So. 3d 840 (¶¶16-18). If that hearing shows a valid strike was denied and the juror served on the jury that convicted, a new trial is required. Id. (¶17); Hardison, 94 So. 3d at 1102. White needed no hearing because his record already showed both things.
What This Means in Mississippi
Once it is final, a published Court of Appeals decision is precedent that circuit courts across the state follow, including the Forrest County Circuit Court in Hattiesburg, the Lamar County Circuit Court in Purvis, the courts of Perry, Jones, Marion, and Covington counties, and Yazoo County, where White arose. The rules it applies, from Stewart and Hardison, already bind those courts.
Section 99-17-3 also requires that the accused be presented a full panel before making his strikes, and a felony conviction requires the unanimous vote of twelve jurors. Miss. R. Crim. P. 18.1(a)(2).
The record saved White's appeal. His lawyer had challenged Juror 30 for cause and stated the reasons again when the strike was questioned, so the transcript showed exactly what happened. The State argued on appeal that White's brief was too thin to raise the issue; the Court of Appeals found it sufficient and added that the error was plain enough to review in any event. White, slip op. at ¶6.
The decision came down on November 3, 2026. Under Mississippi Rule of Appellate Procedure 40(a), the State may ask the Court of Appeals for rehearing within 14 days, which runs to November 17, 2026, and may then ask the Mississippi Supreme Court to review it. Confirm that it has become final before relying on it in a filing.
What to Do If This Affects You
- Before trial, tell your lawyer everything you know about the people on the panel. Who works with the prosecutor's office, who knows the witnesses, who attends church with them. Those facts are what a cause challenge and a peremptory strike are built on.
- Insist that jury selection be put on the record. The strikes, the objections, the reasons given, and the rulings all have to appear in the transcript. White won because his record showed exactly what happened.
- If a judge refused one of your strikes and that juror served, get the jury selection transcript now. Whether the juror sat on the jury that convicted you decides the remedy. A notice of appeal is generally due 30 days after sentencing or after the denial of a timely post-trial motion, whichever is later (M.R.A.P. 4(e)).
- If your direct appeal is over, ask about post-conviction relief. A motion under Mississippi Code Section 99-39-5 generally must be filed within three years, and since July 1, 2026 it needs leave of the Mississippi Supreme Court first when the conviction was affirmed on appeal, when the denial of an earlier post-conviction motion was affirmed on appeal, or when more than three years have passed since the time to appeal ran out (Section 99-39-7). The claims that can be raised there are limited, and a claim that could have been raised on direct appeal may be barred, so get advice before filing.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a judge in Mississippi refuse my lawyer's peremptory strike?
Not without a proper Batson analysis. Under Hardison v. State (Miss. 2012), a judge cannot take away a peremptory strike unless the three Batson steps are completed and show the strike was discriminatory. In White v. State (Miss. Ct. App. Nov. 3, 2026), the Court of Appeals held that a judge who denied a defense strike the State's Batson objection never covered had "no ground on which to refuse it," and the conviction was reversed. A peremptory strike does not have to meet the standard for a challenge for cause.
What is a reverse-Batson challenge?
Batson v. Kentucky bars using peremptory strikes to remove jurors because of race. When the State objects that the defense is doing that, Mississippi courts call it a reverse-Batson challenge. The three steps are the same: the objecting side must first show facts raising an inference of discrimination, then the striking side gives a race-neutral reason, and then the judge decides whether that reason is a pretext.
How many peremptory strikes does each side get in a Mississippi criminal trial?
Under Mississippi Code Section 99-17-3, the defendant and the State each get twelve peremptory challenges in a capital case and six in any other criminal case. The State must make its strikes before a juror is presented to the accused, and the accused must be presented a full panel before making his strikes.
What happens if a judge wrongly denies a peremptory strike and that juror sits on the jury?
Under Hardison v. State (Miss. 2012), prejudice is automatically presumed when a wrongly seated juror serves on the jury that convicts, and the conviction is reversed for a new trial. White v. State applied that rule in November 2026. When the error is that the judge skipped steps of the Batson analysis, the Mississippi Supreme Court held in Miles v. State (2022) that the case may go back for a limited hearing on the existing record.
Is White v. State final?
As of November 15, 2026, it is not final. The decision came down on November 3, 2026. Under Mississippi Rule of Appellate Procedure 40(a), a motion for rehearing is due within 14 days, which runs to November 17, 2026, and the State may then petition the Mississippi Supreme Court for certiorari. Check the case's status before citing it in a filing.
Who handles jury trials and criminal appeals at Lowrey, Fortner, & Miri?
A. Arman Miri leads the criminal defense practice at Lowrey, Fortner, & Miri P.A., which tries felony cases in the circuit courts of Forrest, Lamar, and the surrounding Pine Belt counties and handles criminal appeals and post-conviction motions. Appeals and post-conviction motions are handled by Partner Tom Fortner with A. Arman Miri and Associate Attorney Valorie G. Cochran. Call (601) 582-5015. After hours, leave a voicemail and we will call you back.
Keep Reading
How capital murder, first-degree, second-degree and manslaughter charges are tried in Mississippi.
How a direct appeal and a post-conviction motion work after a Mississippi conviction.
The steps of a Mississippi felony case, from arrest through trial and sentencing.
Talk to a Lawyer
A felony trial is decided by twelve people, and the strikes used to pick them happen before the first witness is called. Lowrey, Fortner, & Miri P.A. tries criminal cases in the Forrest County and Lamar County circuit courts and across the Pine Belt, and handles direct appeals and post-conviction motions when a trial went wrong. Learn more on our criminal defense and appeals and post-conviction pages.
Facing a Felony Trial or an Appeal in Mississippi?
Call Lowrey, Fortner, & Miri P.A. before jury selection or before your appeal deadline passes. Every case turns on its own facts and law, and prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
(601) 582-5015A. Arman Miri is a partner at Lowrey, Fortner, & Miri P.A. in Hattiesburg. He focuses his practice on criminal defense and appellate matters in state and federal court.